Some reflections on the collapse of PM Law

The PM Law group of firms collapsed in February 2026.  In total, almost £40 million of client money had been removed or was missing; tens of thousands of clients were left stranded in the middle of house moves, claims for personal injuries, dealing with the estates of loved ones, and so on; and about 600 staff lost their jobs (quite literally overnight).  This was a tragedy with huge human and financial costs that we must not lose sight of.

It’s perhaps important to say that this collapse was not caused by the regulator; and also that the great majority of solicitors are competent and ethical, working hard to comply with their regulatory obligations.  Equally, no regulator or system of regulation can achieve a zero-risk outcome where nothing bad ever happens; and whatever has gone wrong here was not because of a lack among the regulator’s staff of individual diligence or willingness to act.  But …

Continue reading →

Market structure: continuing growth in the solicitors’ profession

The Law Society of England & Wales recently published its Annual Statistics Report for 2021, its compendium and analysis of useful numbers about the trends in the solicitors profession.  (In fact, it is the second report published this year, the 2020 report having been delayed by the Covid pandemic.)

I have followed these reports for many years, charting the ups and downs in the trends.  I was therefore brought up short by this comment by the President of the Law Society, as reported in Legal Futures: “The decline in the number of firms also highlights the need for widespread investment in our justice system including legal aid rates to ensure lawyers are there when needed.”

The reason that I. Stephanie Boyce’s comment grabbed my attention is that the two elements of the sentence (decline and need for public investment) do not on the face of it appear to be supported by the data or even connected.  Some further digging into the report and other sources was called for. Continue reading →

Is the BigLaw business model sustainable?

This is the question that I was recently given five minutes to answer! This post is intended as a more expanded response. It begs some prior questions about what we mean by ‘BigLaw’, ‘business model’ and ‘the BigLaw business model’. But [spoiler alert] the short and long answers are the same: it doesn’t look like it.

Continue reading →